Why There Is No “Universal” Screw Design for All Polymers

A common question in polymer processing is: “Why can’t there be one screw design that processes all plastics?”

While many people assume “plastic” is a single category, in reality each polymer type has very different processing behaviors. These differences in thermal properties, viscoelasticity, density, and friction make it nearly impossible to design a universal screw that operates at peak efficiency across all materials.

Core Functions of an Extruder Screw

Every single-screw extruder screw performs three essential functions:

1. Solid conveying

2. Melting

3. Metering and pumping

Each function is heavily influenced by the inherent properties of the polymer being processed. That is why a screw design optimized for one polymer often performs poorly with another.

Case Study: HDPE vs. HIPS Energy Requirements

Comparing high-density polyethylene (HDPE) with high-impact polystyrene (HIPS) illustrates these differences.

• Both have similar processing temperatures, but HDPE has a higher specific heat (0.55 Btu/lb-°F) than HIPS (0.40 Btu/lb-°F). This means heating HDPE requires 37.5% more horsepower than HIPS.

• Additionally, HDPE is a crystalline material and requires extra heat of fusion (100 Btu/lb) to melt, while HIPS is amorphous with no distinct melting point.

• Overall, HDPE needs nearly 50% more total power than HIPS to reach processing temperature.

Viscoelastic and Density Effects

Polymers also differ in their viscoelastic properties, which control how viscosity responds to temperature and shear rate:

• Power law index (n): sensitivity to shear rate

• Consistency index (m): sensitivity to temperature

HIPS shows 50% higher viscosity response to shear than HDPE.

Density differences also matter. HDPE has ~90% the solid density of polystyrene but only 77% of its melt density. When HDPE melts, crystalline structures break down, causing volume expansion and reducing throughput (lbs/hr). To compensate, screw channels for HDPE must be 38% deeper with adjusted compression ratios. However, applying this design to HIPS leads to poor melting due to its different viscosity behavior.

Friction Characteristics in Feeding and Melting

Feeding efficiency depends on pellet shape, bulk density, and both internal friction (pellet-to-pellet) and external friction (pellet-to-metal surfaces).

Studies show polystyrene has a 50% higher coefficient of friction against steel than HDPE, which changes feeding rates and early solid-bed compaction inside the screw channel. This directly affects melting efficiency.

The Challenge of Balancing Polymer Properties

Screw design must balance these differences, and sometimes one property offsets another. For example, while HDPE and HIPS are widely used, designing a screw that efficiently processes both is extremely difficult. Extending this idea to polymers with higher melting points (like PC) or hygroscopic materials requiring pre-drying makes the challenge even greater.

Each variation in polymer properties can significantly influence energy efficiency, melt quality, and production cost. Therefore, screws must be tailored to specific polymers for optimal performance.

Scaling Successful Screw Designs

Once a screw is optimized for a specific polymer, it is not necessary to redesign it completely for every size. Through scale-up or scale-down design ratios, the same geometry can be applied to other screw diameters while maintaining performance. This method works effectively except in extreme size ranges, ensuring consistency across production needs.

NANJING HAISI is professional manufacturer of Plastic Extruder Machine, we supply Twin Screw Extruder, Single Screw Extruder, Plastic Recycling Extruder, Two Stage Extruder, Lab Scale Extruder, Mixing and Feeding Machine, Cooling and Pelletizing Machine, Crushing Machine and so on.